Flutter may sound like a benign word when associated with a flag in a breeze, a butterfly, or seaweed in an ocean current. When used in the context of aerodynamics, however, it describes a highly dangerous, potentially deadly condition. Consider the case of the Lockheed L-188 Electra Turboprop, an airliner that first took to the skies in 1957. Two years later, an Electra plummeted to the ground en route from Houston to Dallas. Within another year, a second Electra crashed. In both cases, all crew and passengers died. Lockheed engineers were at a loss as to why the planes wings were tearing off in midair. For an answer, the company turned to NASA s Transonic Dynamics Tunnel (TDT) at Langley Research Center. At the time, the newly renovated wind tunnel offered engineers the capability of testing aeroelastic qualities in aircraft flying at transonic speeds near or just below the speed of sound. (Aeroelasticity is the interaction between aerodynamic forces and the structural dynamics of an aircraft or other structure.) Through round-the-clock testing in the TDT, NASA and industry researchers discovered the cause: flutter. Flutter occurs when aerodynamic forces acting on a wing cause it to vibrate. As the aircraft moves faster, certain conditions can cause that vibration to multiply and feed off itself, building to greater amplitudes until the flutter causes severe damage or even the destruction of the aircraft. Flutter can impact other structures as well. Famous film footage of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge in Washington in 1940 shows the main span of the bridge collapsing after strong winds generated powerful flutter forces. In the Electra s case, faulty engine mounts allowed a type of flutter known as whirl flutter, generated by the spinning propellers, to transfer to the wings, causing them to vibrate violently enough to tear off. Thanks to the NASA testing, Lockheed was able to correct the Electra s design flaws that led to the flutter conditions and return the aircraft to safe flight. Today, all aircraft must have a flutter boundary 15 percent beyond the aircraft s expected maximum speed to ensure that flutter conditions are not encountered in flight. NASA continues to support research in new aircraft designs to improve knowledge of aeroelasticity and flutter. Through platforms such as Dryden Flight Research Center s Active Aeroelastic Wing (AAW) research aircraft, the Agency researches methods for in-flight validation of predictions and for controlling and taking advantage of aeroelastic conditions to enhance aircraft performance.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Modeling Programs Increase Aircraft Design Safety


    Published in:

    Publication date :

    2012-02-01


    Type of media :

    Miscellaneous


    Type of material :

    No indication


    Language :

    English




    A System Safety Model for Developmental Aircraft Programs

    E. J. Amberboy / R. L. Stokeld | NTIS | 1982


    STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS TO INCREASE SAFETY OF AIRCRAFT WITH SOFT WING

    SHVED JURIJ VITALEVICH | European Patent Office | 2016

    Free access

    Safety of aging aircraft - Boeing programs for the 1990's

    HARRADINE, P. / MILLER, M. | AIAA | 1991


    Use of Computer Programs in Aircraft Design

    Stone, Melvin | SAE Technical Papers | 1965


    Aircraft maintenance programs

    Barrera, David Lapesa | TIBKAT | 2022