Travel-related and damage-avoidance benefits and costs of conducting seismic retrofit improvements to arterial bridges are examined, with consideration of the risk posed by a relatively low probability but high damage earthquake (a design level event). The city of Seattle’s arterial bridges and viaduct structures serve as vital components of the urban road network, providing for the ongoing transportation needs of citizens and commerce. Failure of these bridges in the event of an earthquake would have significant negative impacts for the movement of people and goods, and thus on the local economy. Shoring up the city’s bridges to resist earthquake damage would clearly bring benefits, thereby preventing the impassable arterial bottlenecks that would otherwise occur. The question is whether or not the potential benefits of seismic retrofit improvements warrant their investment costs, thereby providing an economically efficient use of public dollars. For the purpose of addressing this question, a methodology for evaluating the potential benefits and costs associated with bridge seismic retrofit improvements is presented, quantifying these impacts for a two-phase retrofit program and considering the results in light of risk and uncertainty. The evaluation procedures developed consider a major earthquake with defined probability and compare the travel-related and damage-avoidance benefits that would be generated by retrofit improvements with their associated implementation costs. Emphasis is placed on travel impacts because researchers would find nontransportation economic impacts extremely difficult to quantify without knowing all of the other physical, built environment impacts that would occur with a major seismic event. Standard measures of economic feasibility are reported, and in the case of Seattle, seismic retrofit improvements demonstrate moderate positive economic rates of return. The implications posed by expected utility theory for risk-averse decision makers in such cases involving earthquake uncertainty are also discussed.


    Access

    Download

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Economic Evaluation of Bridge Seismic Retrofit Improvements


    Additional title:

    Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board


    Contributors:


    Publication date :

    2000-01-01




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English




    Seismic Retrofit of 1958 Carquinez Bridge

    Hinman, John / Toan, Vong / Thoman, Steve | Transportation Research Record | 1998


    Seismic Retrofit of 1958 Carquinez Bridge

    Hinman, John | Online Contents | 1998


    Seismic Retrofit of California's Auburn–Foresthill Bridge

    Reno, Mark L. / Pohll, Martin N. | Transportation Research Record | 2010


    Seismic Retrofit of Vincent Thomas Suspension Bridge

    Baker, George / Ingham, Tim / Heathcote, Dan | Transportation Research Record | 1998