The HFF (hallow fine fiber) and SW (spiral wound) membrane permeators were installed in parallel units of a reverse osmosis (RO) pilot plant. Brackish feed water to the two units was treated with identical scale control treatment consisting of 6 ppm of sodium-hexa-meta phosphate (SHMP) and about 46 ppm (98 % basis) of sulfuric acid. The pH of the acidified feed was about 6.4. Unit 1, employing the HFF membrane, was operated at feed pressure of 27.6 bar (400 psig) and unit 2, employing the SW membrane, was operated at 15.2 bar (220 psig). The water recovery in both units was 70 %. The pilot plant trial lasted for 7.500 h. The techno-economic evaluation showed that performance of the SW membrane was far superior; its product TDS (total diluted salt) in 7500 h was 86-98 ppm wheras that of the HFF membrane increased from 80 ppm to 468 ppm. Water output of both membranes declined appreciably, but output of the SW membrane declined 12 % less. The average electrical energy consumed by high pressure pump of the SW membrane was nearly half the energy consumed by the HFF membrane (0.70 kWh/m3 product vs. 1.51 for HFF). Variations in the pressure drops across the HFF and SW permeators were modest (5-10 psi) due to amorphous nature of the scale deposits found on fibers of both membranes and due to significant decrease in feed flows experienced by the permeators. The pretreatment, the scale control treatment cost and water recovery being the same for the two units, the SW membrane produced excellent quality water (86 ppm) at half the electrical energy cost compared with the HFF membrane which produced 468 ppm water. The SW membrane out-performed the HFF membrane.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Hollow fine fiber vs. spiral-wound RO desalination membranes. Part 1: Pilot plant evaluation


    Additional title:

    Vergleich von Hohlfaser- und Wendel-Umkehrosmose-Entsalzungsmembranen Teil 1: Erarbeitung im Pilotmaßstab


    Contributors:
    Butt, F.H. (author) / Rahman, F. (author) / Baduruthamal, U. (author)

    Published in:

    Desalination ; 109 , 1 ; 67-82


    Publication date :

    1997


    Size :

    16 Seiten, 11 Bilder, 9 Tabellen, 23 Quellen




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Print


    Language :

    English





    Water desalination by pervaporation with hollow fiber membranes

    Korngold, E. / Korin, E. / Ladizhensky, I. | Tema Archive | 1996


    Hydrophilic hollow fiber membranes for water desalination by the pervaporation method

    Korin, E. / Ladizhensky, I. / Korngold, E. | Tema Archive | 1996



    Pilot plant evaluation of advances vs. conventional scale inhibitors for RO desalination

    Butt, F.H. / Rahman, F. / Baduruthamal, U. | Tema Archive | 1995