In this study the simulation of street canyon flow was investigated. Since the same numerical method was used and the solutions were grid-independent, it can be concluded that the main differences between the simulations were caused by the turbulence modeling. Unfortunately none of the used turbulence closure schemes led to a fully satisfying result demonstrating that predicting the flow in street canyons is a challenging problem for RANS calculations. The k-e model showed a qualitatively reasonable solution, but was quantitatively relative poor in comparison with the LDV measurements. Counterintuitively, the more advanced SST and SSG models did not produce better results. The rooftop recirculation zone was over-estimated severely, causing a qualitatively different flow field inside the canyon. As a consequence, one should be very careful in interpreting the results of a RANS calculation for this kind of flow. The variation of solutions between the different turbulence models is so large that there is a very high uncertainty factor. In conclusion, we recommend that within a series of RANS parameter studies, ke simuations, if possible, are either validated by means of wind tunnel experiments or LES. Alternatively, to strike a balance between inexpensive RANS calculations and high-fidelity but costly LES, it might be worthwhile to employ hybrid LES/RANS methods. Such methods have shown great promise for the simulation of complex turbulent flows, see the review of Fröhlich and von Terzi [2008]. Furthermore, some of these methods are already available in commercial CFD software.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Scrutinizing turbulence closure schemes for predicting the flow in street canyons


    Contributors:


    Publication date :

    2006


    Size :

    8 Seiten, 8 Bilder, 1 Tabelle, 8 Quellen



    Type of media :

    Conference paper


    Type of material :

    Print


    Language :

    English




    Car emission dispersion in urban street canyons

    Rafailidis, S. / Commission of the European Communities | British Library Conference Proceedings | 1994



    Modeling traffic-related air pollution in street canyons of Beijing

    Fu, Lixin / Hao, Jiming / Hertel, O. et al. | Tema Archive | 2000


    Street Canyons and Quiet Side: Comparing FDTD Simulation and Engineering Models

    De Muer, T. / Van Renterghem, T. / De Greve, B. et al. | British Library Conference Proceedings | 2004