The safety of increasingly automated vehicles is of great concern to regulators, yet crash rates are generally reported by manufacturers using proprietary metrics with limited source data. Without consistent definitions of crashes and exposure, automated vehicle crash rates cannot be meaningfully compared with baseline datasets. The objective of this study was to establish methods to normalize automated vehicle crash rates using one manufacturer’s crash reports as a case study. The manufacturer’s quarterly crash rates for vehicles using SAE Level 1 and Level 2 automation were compared. Road type was controlled for using data from a naturalistic driving study with the same model vehicles, while driver age was controlled for using demographic ownership surveys. Although Level 2 vehicles were claimed to have a 43% lower crash rate than Level 1 vehicles, their improvement was only 10% after controlling for different rates of freeway driving. Direct comparison with general public driving was impossible due to unclear crash severity thresholds in the manufacturer’s reports, but analysis showed that controlling for driver age would increase reported crash rates by 11%. These results establish the need for detailed crash data, crash definitions, and exposure and demographic data in order to accurately assess automated vehicle safety.


    Access

    Check access

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Normalizing crash risk of partially automated vehicles under sparse data


    Additional title:

    N. Goodall
    Journal of Transportation Safety & Security


    Contributors:

    Published in:

    Publication date :

    2024-01-02


    Size :

    17 pages




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English




    Potential Crash Rate Benchmarks for Automated Vehicles

    Goodall, Noah J. | Transportation Research Record | 2021



    Method and system for normalizing and comparing GPS data from multiple vehicles

    KLIMEK TOMASZ R | European Patent Office | 2015

    Free access


    Impact of connected vehicles on mitigating secondary crash risk

    Hong Yang / Zhenyu Wang / Kun Xie | DOAJ | 2017

    Free access