This paper compares several blade element theory (BET) method-based propeller simulation tools, including an evaluation against static propeller ground tests and high-fidelity Reynolds-Average Navier Stokes (RANS) simulations. Two proprietary propeller geometries for paraglider applications are analysed in static and flight conditions. The RANS simulations are validated with the static test data and used as a reference for comparing the BET in flight conditions. The comparison includes the analysis of varying 2D aerodynamic airfoil parameters and different induced velocity calculation methods. The evaluation of the BET propeller simulation tools shows the strength of the BET tools compared to RANS simulations. The RANS simulations underpredict static experimental data within 10% relative error, while appropriate BET tools overpredict the RANS results by 15–20% relative error. A variation in 2D aerodynamic data depicts the need for highly accurate 2D data for accurate BET results. The nonlinear BET coupled with XFOIL for the 2D aerodynamic data matches best with RANS in static operation and flight conditions. The novel BET tool PropCODE combines both approaches and offers further correction models for highly accurate static and flight condition results.


    Access

    Download


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Comparison and evaluation of blade element methods against RANS simulations and test data


    Additional title:

    CEAS Aeronaut J


    Contributors:
    Bergmann, Ole (author) / Götten, F. (author) / Braun, C. (author) / Janser, F. (author)

    Published in:

    CEAS Aeronautical Journal ; 13 , 2 ; 535-557


    Publication date :

    2022-04-01


    Size :

    23 pages




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English





    Comparison of RANS Simulations of Multi-Element High-Lift Configurations

    Murayama, Mitsuhiro / Imamura, Taro / Yamamoto, Kazuomi et al. | AIAA | 2006


    Comparison between RANS and hybrid RANS/LES simulations of jet/vortex interaction

    Chmielarski, Vivien / Ghedhaifi, Weeded / Montreuil, Emmanuel et al. | AIAA | 2019


    A Blade Element Theory Based Actuator Disk Methodology for Modeling of Fan Engines in RANS Simulations

    Spinner, Sebastian / Keller, Dennis / Schnell, Rainer et al. | German Aerospace Center (DLR) | 2020

    Free access

    A Blade Element Theory Based Actuator Disk Methodology for Modeling of Fan Engines in RANS Simulations

    Spinner, Sebastian / Keller, Dennis / Schnell, Rainer et al. | AIAA | 2020


    A BLADE ELEMENT THEORY BASED ACTUATOR DISK METHODOLOGY FOR MODELING OF FAN ENGINES IN RANS SIMULATIONS

    Spinner, Sebastian / Keller, Dennis / Schnell, Rainer et al. | TIBKAT | 2020