Abstract The scaling approach is a statistical estimation method that allows for differences in the amount of unexplained variation in different types of data, which can then be used together in the analysis. This approach has been mostly used in context of combining Stated Preference and Revealed Preference data, but has also been used as a method of identifying systematic differences in the variance of choices within a single Stated Preference data set, e.g. for investigation of learning and fatigue effects. This paper investigates whether a scaling approach is suitable for handling inconsistencies in Stated Choice data. Both the number of inconsistent choices, based on a test of violations of the transitivity axiom, and education are used as scaling variables. Scaling effects appear to exist due to inconsistent choices, and the amount of unexplained variance is shown to increase as the number of inconsistent choice increase. Scaling due to inconsistencies significantly improves the models and reduces the valuations of travel time. In addition, the scaling approach makes the valuations of travel time from the Stated Choice data more consistent with the valuations from Contingent Valuation data included in the same study. In spite of the fact that education is the only significant explanatory variable for the number of inconsistent choices, scaling due to education gives no significant improvement in the model.
Inconsistent choices in Stated Choice data;Use of the logit scaling approach to handle resulting variance increases
Transportation ; 28 , 3
2001
Article (Journal)
English
Efficient stated choice experiments for estimating nested logit models
Online Contents | 2009
|Non-trading, lexicographic and inconsistent behaviour in stated choice data
Online Contents | 2010
|Efficient stated choice experiments for estimating nested logit models
Online Contents | 2009
|Dual-Response Choices in Pivoted Stated Choice Experiments
Online Contents | 2009
|Dual-Response Choices in Pivoted Stated Choice Experiments
Transportation Research Record | 2009
|