This paper discusses and analyses whether congestion charges can be considered to be “fair” in different senses of the word. Two different perspectives are distinguished: the consumer perspective and the citizen perspective. The consumer perspective is the traditional one in equity analyses, and includes changes in travel costs, travel times and so on. Using data from four European cities, I show that high-income groups pay more than low-income groups, but low-income groups pay a larger share of their income. I argue that which of these distributional measures is most appropriate depends on the purpose(s) of the charging system. The citizen perspective is about individuals’ views of social issues such as equity, procedural fairness and environmental issues. I argue that an individual can be viewed as a “winner” from a citizen perspective if a reform (such as congestion pricing) is aligned with her views of what is socially desirable. Using the same data set, I analyse to what extent different income groups “win” or “lose” from a citizen perspective – i.e., to what extent congestion pricing is aligned with the societal preferences of high- and low-income groups. It turns out that these differences are small, but overall, middle-income groups “win” the most in this sense.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Is congestion pricing fair? Consumer and citizen perspectives on equity effects


    Contributors:

    Published in:

    Transport policy ; 52 ; 1-15


    Publication date :

    2016




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Print


    Language :

    English



    Classification :

    BKL:    55.80 Verkehrswesen, Transportwesen: Allgemeines / 74.75 Verkehrsplanung, Verkehrspolitik



    Is congestion pricing fair? Consumer and citizen perspectives on equity effects

    Eliasson, Jonas | British Library Online Contents | 2016


    Equity effects of congestion pricing

    Eliasson, Jonas | Online Contents | 2006


    Role of Context in Equity Effects of Congestion Pricing

    Franklin, Joel P | Online Contents | 2012


    Role of Context in Equity Effects of Congestion Pricing

    Franklin, Joel P. | Transportation Research Record | 2012


    Equity Issues of Congestion Pricing: Definition, Evaluation, and Promotion

    Chu, Zhaoming / Cheng, Lin / Tang, Wenyun | ASCE | 2013