Most studies find strong evidence that motorcycle helmets protect against injury, but a small number of controversial studies have reported a positive association between helmet use and neck injury. The most commonly cited paper is that of Goldstein (1986). Goldstein obtained and reanalyzed data from the Hurt Study, a prospective, on-scene investigation of 900 motorcycle collisions in the city of Los Angeles. The Goldstein results have been adopted by the anti-helmet community to justify resistance to compulsory motorcycle helmet use on the grounds that helmets may cause neck injuries due to their mass. In the current study, we replicated Goldstein's models to understand how he obtained his unexpected results, and we then applied modern statistical methods to estimate the association of motorcycle helmet use with head injury, fatal injury, and neck injury among collision-involved motorcyclists. We found Goldstein's analysis to be critically flawed due to improper data imputation, modeling of extremely sparse data, and misinterpretation of model coefficients. Our new analysis showed that motorcycle helmets were associated with markedly lower risk of head injury (RR 0.40, 95% CI 0.31-0.52) and fatal injury (RR 0.44, 95% CI 0.26-0.74) and with moderately lower but statistically significant risk of neck injury (RR 0.63, 95% CI 0.40-0.99), after controlling for multiple potential confounders.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Motorcycle helmet use and the risk of head, neck, and fatal injury: Revisiting the Hurt Study



    Published in:

    Publication date :

    2016




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Print


    Language :

    English



    Classification :

    BKL:    44.80 / 55.84 Straßenverkehr / 55.24 / 44.80 Unfallmedizin, Notfallmedizin / 55.84 / 55.24 Fahrzeugführung, Fahrtechnik




    Analysis of Motorcycle Helmet Use in Fatal Crashes

    T. M. Pickrell / M. Starnes | NTIS | 2008


    Fatal motorcycle accidents and helmet laws in Peninsular Malaysia

    Supramaniam, Veerappan / van Belle, Gerald / Sung, John F.C. | Elsevier | 1983


    Head and Neck Injuries in Fatal Motorcycle Collisions as Determined by Detailed Autopsy

    Kasantikul, V. / Ouellet, J. / Smith, T. et al. | British Library Conference Proceedings | 2002


    Head and neck responses in oblique motorcycle helmet impacts: a novel laboratory test method

    Pang, T. Y. / Thai, K. T. / McIntosh, A. S. et al. | Taylor & Francis Verlag | 2011