This research investigated how different experts in a single domain chose their individual subjective evaluation criteria of a highly aggregate task based upon their individual differences. The Conning Officer Virtual Environment (COVE) was utilized to provide a domain of experts and a subjectively evaluated task. 116 expert ship-handlers were investigated to understand how their personality affects their evaluation of a novice performing an underway replenishment (UNREP). The experts were issued a survey that inventoried their personality, UNREP evaluation criteria, and ship handling style. In general, the participant experts were lower in Neuroticism and higher in Extraversion and Conscientiousness than the average adult. Extraversion appeared to be correlated with the expert's desire to use sensory input as a critical evaluation criterion (p=.18) while Openness was correlated with analytical input (p=.16) and UNREP style (p=.16) as critical evaluation factors. Also correlated with UNREP style was Agreeableness (p=.16). Finally, the expert's level of Conscientiousness correlated with the critical evaluation criteria of analytical input (p=.17) and sensory input (p=.39). Results from this research provide insight to the link between observed behavior and its subjective evaluation and will allow COVE's programmers to develop an Intelligent Tutoring System (ITS) that will customize the automated training process.
Role of Personality in Determining Variability in Evaluating Expertise
2000
120 pages
Report
No indication
English
Military Sciences , Psychology , Psychiatry , Computers, Control & Information Theory , Judgement(Psychology) , Job analysis , Personality , Theses , Computer graphics , Replenishment at sea , Naval training , Ship handling , Intelligent tutoring systems , Interactive learning , Five factor model , COVE(Conning Office Virtual Environment) , Personnel evaluation
Maritieme Expertise - Expertise van motorschade Deel 1
Online Contents | 2003
Maritieme Expertise - Expertise van motorschaden, deel 2
Online Contents | 2003
Online Contents | 2003
TIBKAT | 1.1966 -