Urban areas considering major transportation investments evaluate alternatives using various techniques such as benefit-cost analysis and cost effectiveness measures. A comprehensive benefit-cost analysis is the least biased method of judging project merit when crossmodal impacts are significant. Using Oklahoma City data, five build alternatives in two corridors were examined using three different evaluation methodologies: (1) user benefit analysis, described in a 1977 American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials manual; (2) cost effectiveness, which employs the Federal Transit Administration's average cost per new transit rider index; and (3) benefit-cost analysis, developed specifically for this study. The alternatives included light rail transit and high occupancy vehicle lanes. The study illustrates how benefit-cost analysis can incorporate important crossmodal interactions by distinguishing between passenger and commercial traffic, and trip purposes and vehicle types. The study demonstrates several innovative methodologies including procedures for calculating user benefits when the travel forecasting model uses a fixed trip table, estimating congestion relief to highway modes resulting from transit investments, and incorporating non-user costs such as air quality, noise, and parking subsidies. When properly applied benefit-cost analysis reveals important transfer payments which are not apparent from other, more aggregate, evaluation techniques. A major finding is that the overall quality of an investment study is heavily dependent on the travel modeling procedures.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Major Investment Analysis for Multimodal Projects in Urban Corridors: Final Report


    Contributors:

    Publication date :

    1996


    Size :

    214 pages


    Type of media :

    Report


    Type of material :

    No indication


    Language :

    English





    Comparing Multimodal Alternatives in Major Travel Corridors

    DeCorla-Souza, P. / Jensen-Fisher, R. / Transportation Research Board | British Library Conference Proceedings | 1994


    Comparing Multimodal Alternatives in Major Travel Corridors

    DeCorla-Souza, Patrick | Online Contents | 1994



    Major Investment Analysis of a Multimodal Project in an Urban Corridor

    Marshment, R. S. | British Library Conference Proceedings | 1995