Following their victories in the Spanish-American War, Admirals William T. Sampson and Winfield Scott Schley engaged in a lively public debate over their respective records at the Battle of Santiago in July 1898. The Spanish admiral, Pascual Cervera, outmaneuvered the North Atlantic Squadron and managed to enter the Cuban harbor at Santiago where he maintained a fleet-in- being. After several failed attempts, a combination of joint actions ashore and at sea lured the Spanish fleet out of the harbor. Cervera was defeated in the ensuing battle. The argument over how the battle should have been fought lasted for years; a Presidential order was needed to stop the debate. The acrimonious enquiry into tactics and doctrine following the Spanish-American War deterred frank and open discussion of doctrine in the Navy for years. One might conclude that the Sampson-Schley debate virtually banished the term doctrine from the naval lexicon, inhibiting a generation of officers from exploring the nature and content of doctrine. Lieutenant Commander Dudley W. Knox wrote a prize- winning essay in 1915, published in the U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings, that attempted to revive doctrine as an issue. While Knox failed to bring doctrinal debate to the fore, doctrine was no longer a forbidden subject. It appeared in tactical publications whose readership was almost exclusively Navy officers. It also took root in the unwritten but extremely powerful form of shared experiences derived from service at sea, fleet exercises, and war college courses. Doctrinal debate resumed in wardrooms and classrooms rather than in professional journals. By World War II there was a mature, formal, and centralized system for developing and evaluating doctrine in the Navy, one that guided rather than directed the fleet commander on how to fight. While conventional wisdom says that the Navy has never had a centralized military doctrine, the U.S. fleet in World War II operated under a series of hierarchical doctr.


    Access

    Access via TIB

    Check availability in my library


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Developing Naval Doctrine...From the Sea


    Contributors:

    Publication date :

    1995


    Size :

    5 pages


    Type of media :

    Report


    Type of material :

    No indication


    Language :

    English




    History of Italian Naval Doctrine

    L. Donolo / J. J. Tritten | NTIS | 1995


    Call for an Official Naval Doctrine

    S. D. Schmidt | NTIS | 1992


    Is there a Place for a Naval Doctrine

    W. H. Roberson | NTIS | 1992