Commonality strategies have become an important means of cost-sharing across systems, particularly in long lifecycle aerospace applications such as the Joint Strike Fighter. However, decreases in realized commonality (divergence) have important implications for the cost-sharing effects of commonality. We review the results of a recent study at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) of 16 firms and 8 Government organization, which was chartered to evaluate the costing of commonality benefits. We conclude that the size of commonality investments has been underestimated — our data reveal the cost of developing common systems is 12%–50% above the unique design cost. We find evidence to suggest that divergence has cost consequences, notability creating higher quality expenses and requiring additional manufacturing coordination. We examine in detail the potential use of development cost allocation as a management practice for incentivizing commonality. We show that lead variants bearing platform costs achieved weaker investment returns and re-captured few benefits from later variants. We propose a framework for evaluating the consequences of each cost allocation, which explicitly captures the impact of individual variant decisions on the platform's cost structure, building on existing work used in decision-making in the Joint Strike Fighter program. We conclude with management guidance gathered from the case studies for reinforcing commonality incentives.


    Access

    Check access

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Costing commonality: Investigating the impact of platform divergence


    Contributors:


    Publication date :

    2012-03-01


    Size :

    681992 byte





    Type of media :

    Conference paper


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English



    Commonality and Interoperability

    Dillon, B. / Association for Unmanned Vehicle Systems | British Library Conference Proceedings | 1994



    Overarching Rotorcraft Commonality Assessment

    Usry, F. / American Helicopter Society | British Library Conference Proceedings | 2000


    Costs drive TFC commonality

    Online Contents | 1996


    Joint Commonality Submersible (JCS)

    YEO CHEE HUI | European Patent Office | 2015

    Free access