Abstract Some criticize the data-driven study of driverless car ethics for relying on deterministic crash scenarios where the focus should be on minimizing the occurrence of accidents instead. Indeed, decisions in road traffic are taken in the domain of risk. A relevant ethical question is, however, whether autonomous vehicles should actually minimize an accident’s probability or rather balance the accident’s probability and severity. While ethicists’ introspections might lead them to different conclusions, a participatory paradigm in ethics demands to include laypeople’s intuitions into the societal debate. In three online studies, we found that the mere minimization of accident probability in ethical dilemmas does not correspond to the views of our sample. Our participants favor a balanced consideration of accident probability and severity. This remains true even if the underlying dilemma is based on a more realistic scenario of allocating minor risks among road users. Our findings furthermore illustrate that trolley problems may be informative for autonomous vehicles and emphasize the importance of transparency if manufacturers and the public do not agree on guiding principles in road traffic.


    Access

    Check access

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Autonomous vehicles and moral judgments under risk


    Contributors:


    Publication date :

    2021-10-25


    Size :

    10 pages




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English




    Autonomous Vehicles: Moral dilemmas and adoption incentives

    Feess, Eberhard / Muehlheusser, Gerd | Elsevier | 2024


    METHOD OF ANALYZING HUMAN MORAL REASONING FOR MORAL DECISION MAKING OF AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES

    LEE JI HYUN / LEE GI BBEUM | European Patent Office | 2019

    Free access

    Moral Dilemma Facing Autonomous Vehicles: A Discrete Choice Model

    Zhu, Siying / Walt Tay, Shen Loong / Hsieh, Cheng-Hsien | IEEE | 2023


    Representations of Risk Judgments

    Mellers, Barbara A. | Online Contents | 1994


    Risk-Based Safety Envelopes for Autonomous Vehicles Under Perception Uncertainty

    Bernhard, Julian / Hart, Patrick / Sahu, Amit et al. | IEEE | 2022