Abstract Elvik (2006) discussed the appropriateness of including the benefits that offenders get when violating traffic laws. While concluding that these benefits could not be given standing, Elvik resorted to argumentation from normative theories outside the schools of economic theory. In this article, we present arguments for omitting violators' benefits, or lost benefits, based on normative stands within economics school of thought. By means of two examples, we illustrate the distinction between a project of increased/improved enforcement of existing speed limits, where violators' time losses should not be included – compatible with Elvik's point of view – and a project of reduced speed limits, where the time loss should be included. This clarification of standing in cost-benefit analysis of road safety measures is based on the economics school of thought, where cost-benefit analysis is regarded as a decision tool operating within social constraints and where speed limits are considered as absolute institutions.

    Highlights Economic theory of cost-benefit analysis provides arguments for omitting traffic law violators' benefits, or lost benefits. Cost-benefit analysis is based on aggregation of individual preferences, but operates within social constraints. Social constraints include institutional settings that dictate that, for example, violation of the speed limit is an illegal activity. Thus, benefits from speeding should not be included in cost-benefit analysis of speed limit enforcement measures. However, for cost-benefit analysis of speed limit reduction, a change in social constraints, time loss should be included.


    Access

    Check access

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Standing in cost-benefit analysis of road safety measures: A case of speed enforcement vs. speed change


    Contributors:

    Published in:

    Transport Policy ; 30 ; 269-274


    Publication date :

    2013-01-01


    Size :

    6 pages




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English





    A systematic cost-benefit analysis of 29 road safety measures

    Daniels, Stijn / Martensen, Heike / Schoeters, Annelies et al. | Elsevier | 2019



    SPEED ENFORCEMENT SYSTEM AND SPEED ENFORCEMENT METHOD

    OKAMURA TOSHIYUKI / YAMAMOTO HISAYOSHI / KASHIHARA MITSURU et al. | European Patent Office | 2018

    Free access