Abstract The possibility that extraterrestrial intelligences (ETIs) could be hostile to humanity has been raised as a reason to avoid even trying to contact ETIs. However, there is a distinct shortage of analytical discussion about the risks of an attack, perhaps because of an implicit premise that we cannot analyze the decision making of an alien civilization. This paper argues that we can draw some inferences from the history of the Cold War and nuclear deterrence in order to show that at least some attack scenarios are likely to be exaggerated. In particular, it would seem to be unlikely that the humanity would be attacked simply because it might, sometime in the future, present a threat to the ETI. Even if communication proves to be difficult, rational decision-makers should avoid unprovoked attacks, because their success would be very difficult to assure. In general, it seems believable that interstellar conflicts between civilizations would remain rare. The findings advise caution for proposed interstellar missions, however, as starfaring capability itself might be seen as a threat. On the other hand, attempting to contact ETIs seems to be a relatively low-risk strategy: paranoid ETIs must also consider the possibility that the messages are a deception designed to lure out hostile civilizations and preemptively destroy them.

    Highlights ► Would ETIs attack humanity preventively, before we could be a threat to them? ► Practical problems of interstellar preventive strike are discussed. ► Even simple interstellar probes could work as retaliatory deterrent. ► Preventive strike turns out to be a high-risk gamble for the attacker.


    Access

    Check access

    Check availability in my library

    Order at Subito €


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    MAD with aliens? Interstellar deterrence and its implications


    Contributors:

    Published in:

    Acta Astronautica ; 86 ; 201-210


    Publication date :

    2013-01-24


    Size :

    10 pages




    Type of media :

    Article (Journal)


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English




    MAD with aliens? Interstellar deterrence and its implications

    Korhonen, Janne M. | Online Contents | 2013


    Deterrence failures and deterrence strategies

    Brown, Michael E. | TIBKAT | 1977


    Making Aliens

    Andreadis, Athena | Online Contents | 2013


    RELAY-ATTACK DETERRENCE RELAY-ATTACK DETERRENCE

    ASMAR RON Y / UTTER THOMAS E / FOREST THOMAS M et al. | European Patent Office | 2017

    Free access

    Relay-attack deterrence relay-attack deterrence

    ASMAR RON Y / UTTER THOMAS E / FOREST THOMAS M et al. | European Patent Office | 2018

    Free access