Autonomous vehicles (AVs) are expected to bring major benefits to transport and society. To exploit this potential, their acceptance by society is a necessary condition. However, AV acceptance is currently at stake: AVs face resistance by bystanders and local communities. Resistance can prevent the implementation and use of AVs, threatening road safety and efficiency. The present study performed a qualitative and quantitative text analysis of comments submitted by locals in San Francisco (SF) to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) on the fared deployment of AVs. The results of the analysis are synthesized, and a conceptual framework explaining and predicting resistance is proposed. The framework posits that the occurrence of resistance is a direct result of the perception of threats, which is determined by individual and system characteristics, direct and indirect consequences of system use, reactions of others, and external events. AVs as threat to safety was associated with their unpredictable, and illegal driving behavior, as well as producing conflict situations. The lack of explicit communication between AVs and other road users due to the absence of a human driver behind the steering wheel negatively contributed to perceived safety and trust, especially for vulnerable populations in crossing situations. Respondents reported a negative impact on road capacity, congestion, and traffic flow, with AVs blocking other road users, such as emergency vehicles. Inaccessible vehicle design contributed to the exclusion of vulnerable groups with disabilities. The scientific dialogue on acceptance of AVs needs to shift towards resistance as the 'other' essential element of acceptance to ensure that we live up to our promise of transitioning towards more sustainable mobility that is inclusive, equitable, fair, just, affordable, and available to all.


    Access

    Download


    Export, share and cite



    Title :

    Understanding and addressing the resistance towards autonomous vehicles (AVs)


    Contributors:

    Publication date :

    2023


    Remarks:

    33 pages, 3 figures



    Type of media :

    Preprint


    Type of material :

    Electronic Resource


    Language :

    English




    Resistance towards autonomous vehicles (AVs)

    S. Nordhoff | DOAJ | 2024

    Free access

    Towards Social Autonomous Vehicles: Understanding Pedestrian-Driver Interactions

    Rasouli, Amir / Kotseruba, Iuliia / Tsotsos, John K. | IEEE | 2018


    Towards Autonomous Vehicles

    C. Schwarz / G. Thomas / K. Nelson et al. | NTIS | 2013


    Towards Robust Situation Awareness in Autonomous Vehicles

    Nine, Julkar | DataCite | 2020

    Free access

    Understanding LiDAR Performance for Autonomous Vehicles Under Snowfall Conditions

    Sun, Chenghao / Sun, Pengpeng / Wang, Jianqiu et al. | IEEE | 2024