Highlights ► We discuss whether different efficiency assessment methodologies result in similar findings. ► Findings suggest that efficiency scores and policy recommendations are sensitive to models used. ► Performance assessment based on averages may yield skewed policy recommendations. ► Efficient systems are generally not effective and vice-versa. ► Systems regulated with contracts are more efficient that public systems.
Abstract The need to measure transit system performance along with its various dimensions such as efficiency and effectiveness has led to the development of a wide array of approaches and vast literature. However, depending upon the specific approach used to examine performance, different conclusions are oftentimes reached. Using data from 15 European transit systems for a ten year time period (1990–2000), this paper discusses three important transit performance questions; (i) Do different efficiency assessment methodologies produce similar results? (ii) How are the two basic dimensions of transit performance, namely efficiency and effectiveness, related? and (iii) Are findings regarding organizational regimes (public operations, contracting and so on) sensitive to the methodological specifications employed? Results clearly indicate that efficiency scores and associated recommendations are sensitive to the models used, while efficiency and effectiveness are – albeit weakly – negatively related; these two findings can have far reaching policy implications.
Efficiency measurement in public transport: Are findings specification sensitive?
Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice ; 46 , 2 ; 392-402
2011-10-11
11 pages
Article (Journal)
Electronic Resource
English
Efficiency measurement in public transport: Are findings specification sensitive?
Online Contents | 2012
|Unobserved Heterogeneity and Efficiency Measurement in Public Transport
Online Contents | 2012
|SAE Technical Papers | 2007
Advanced Public Transport Passenger Information: Findings of the EuroBus-Project
British Library Conference Proceedings | 1993
|