Abstract PPP projects that go bankrupt come to early termination and are usually considered a complete failure. While it is true that this outcome is catastrophic for the project shareholders and creditors, it may not be the case for other relevant stakeholders, such as the granting authority, users and society as a whole. Assessing the global outcome of the project requires several detailed ex-post analyses, such as financial analysis, cost-benefit analysis and value for money analysis. Unfortunately, these analyses are seldom performed. To illustrate this point a case study was analysed: the PPP contract for two toll motorways (R-3 and R-5) and a segment of a ring road (M-50) in the vicinity of Madrid, Spain. The results show that the cost of the project to the Government, although higher than estimated on the pre-feasibility study, will be significantly lower than the first and hasty estimates. The project, despite a lower demand than initially expected, is still highly beneficial to society. Finally, using a PPP for this project has allowed the Granting Authority to avoid risks that have materialized with an important cost.
Highlights Some public-private partnership (PPP) projects come to an early termination due to the bankruptcy of the concessionaire. These projects are generally considered a failure – usually true for the shareholders of the special purpose vehicle (SPV). For the Granting Authority and the users, the project may be a success in spite of the SPV's bankruptcy. Ex-post financial analysis, cost-benefit analysis and value for money analysis need to be performed. A bankrupt PPP project that was (at least partially) successful is the concession of Spanish R-3 and R-5 toll highways. Likewise, it might be unfair to consider a PPP project successful only because the SPV is obtaining a good financial return.
Bankrupt PPPs: Is it really so bad? Case study of R-3 and R-5 toll motorways in Spain
Transport Policy ; 114 ; 78-87
2021-09-13
10 pages
Article (Journal)
Electronic Resource
English
Government-owned toll motorways
Engineering Index Backfile | 1928
|Strassenverkehr - Japan's toll motorways
Online Contents | 2001
|Typical autostrade in Italy (toll motorways)
Engineering Index Backfile | 1928
|Twenty-Five Years of Toll Motorways in Spain: Looking into the Future
British Library Conference Proceedings | 1995
|Shifting Death to Their Alternatives The Case of Toll Motorways
Online Contents | 2011
|