During the past few decades, there have been two parallel streams of driving behavior research: models using trajectory data collected from the field (using video recordings, GPS, etc.) and models using data from driving simulators (in which the behavior of the drivers is recorded in controlled laboratory conditions). Although the former source of data is more realistic, it lacks information about the driver and is typically not suitable for testing effects of future vehicle technologies and traffic scenarios. In contrast, driving behavior models developed with driving simulator data may lack behavioral realism. However, no previous study has compared these two streams of mathematical models and investigated the transferability of the models developed with driving simulator data to real field conditions in a rigorous manner. The current study aimed to fill this research gap by investigating the transferability of two car-following models between a driving simulator and two comparable real-life traffic motorway scenarios, one from the United Kingdom and the other one from the United States. In this regard, stimulus–response–based car-following models were developed with three microscopic data sources: ( a) experimental data collected from the University of Leeds driving simulator, ( b) detailed trajectory data collected from UK Motorway 1, and ( c) detailed trajectory data collected from Interstate 80 in California. The parameters of these car-following models were estimated by using the maximum likelihood estimation technique, and the transferability of the models was investigated by using statistical tests of parameter equivalence and transferability test statistics. Estimation results indicate transferability at the model level but not fully at the parameter level for both pairs of scenarios.
Transferability of Car-Following Models Between Driving Simulator and Field Traffic
Transportation Research Record
Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board ; 2623 , 1 ; 60-72
2017-01-01
Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)
Elektronische Ressource
Englisch
Determining the transferability of flight simulator data
NTRS | 1992
|Modular driving simulator and traffic simulation
British Library Conference Proceedings | 1997
|A full driving simulator of urban traffic including traffic accidents
Tema Archiv | 2007
|Adaptive traffic parameter prediction: Effect of number of states and transferability of models
Online Contents | 2016
|