The idea of a responsible cosmopolitan state (RCS) represents a recent attempt to reconcile the utopianism of cosmopolitan political theory and the practical constraints arising from the current realities of politics among territorial and largely self-interested states. I show in this chapter that the neorealist and/or geopolitical challenge rests on a misconception about what cosmopolitanism is meant to provide, because immediate practical advice is only a part of what normative political theory may bring to the table. Besides the notion of self-interest, which can be interpreted in different ways, it is mainly the action-modifying role of norms (especially international/supranational law) which may gradually change the game. Since the sustenance of state capacities is often preconditioned by events which take place beyond state borders, shared rules of conduct allow for more effective coordination in cases where collective action is required. Although the idea of an RCS primarily targets foreign policy priorities of smaller/weaker states (not-great-powers), it may turn out that collective action problems arising from the empirical realities of the twenty-first century increasingly put great powers under pressure to accept such self-imposed constraints and comply with them. In the final part of the chapter, however, I explain why this ‘cosmopolitan optimism’ needs to be aware of its own limitations, singling out the problems of the internal motivation of actors in world politics and the deeper meaning of sovereignty which precludes an easy switch to the language of dispersed, pooled, or relational sovereignty. I conclude by arguing that if we are to take cosmopolitan ideals seriously, the RCS most likely represents a transitional stage on the route towards a centralised global political authority.
Reconciling Cosmopolitan Theory and Policy Practice? Responsible States as a Transitional Category
Spa. Soc.
2022-04-23
16 pages
Aufsatz/Kapitel (Buch)
Elektronische Ressource
Englisch
International Security Regimes, Space and Responsible Cosmopolitan States
Springer Verlag | 2022
|Responsible Cosmopolitan State in Space Politics
Springer Verlag | 2022
|DataCite | 1916