HighlightsA Bayesian hierarchical model for predicting road safety hotspots is proposed.The model extends the classical empirical Bayes method to include data from multiple time-points.The model incorporates adjustments for regression-to-mean and global/local trend.A variance inflation device gives more recent observations more weight in the model.Validation diagnostics suggest the model predicts extremely well, with a high degree of accuracy.
AbstractIn this paper, we propose a Bayesian hierarchical model for predicting accident counts in future years at sites within a pool of potential road safety hotspots. The aim is to inform road safety practitioners of the location of likely future hotspots to enable a proactive, rather than reactive, approach to road safety scheme implementation. A feature of our model is the ability to rank sites according to their potential to exceed, in some future time period, a threshold accident count which may be used as a criterion for scheme implementation. Our model specification enables the classical empirical Bayes formulation – commonly used in before-and-after studies, wherein accident counts from a single before period are used to estimate counterfactual counts in the after period – to be extended to incorporate counts from multiple time periods. This allows site-specific variations in historical accident counts (e.g. locally-observed trends) to offset estimates of safety generated by a global accident prediction model (APM), which itself is used to help account for the effects of global trend and regression-to-mean (RTM). The Bayesian posterior predictive distribution is exploited to formulate predictions and to properly quantify our uncertainty in these predictions. The main contributions of our model include (i) the ability to allow accident counts from multiple time-points to inform predictions, with counts in more recent years lending more weight to predictions than counts from time-points further in the past; (ii) where appropriate, the ability to offset global estimates of trend by variations in accident counts observed locally, at a site-specific level; and (iii) the ability to account for unknown/unobserved site-specific factors which may affect accident counts. We illustrate our model with an application to accident counts at 734 potential hotspots in the German city of Halle; we also propose some simple diagnostics to validate the predictive capability of our model. We conclude that our model accurately predicts future accident counts, with point estimates from the predictive distribution matching observed counts extremely well.
A novel Bayesian hierarchical model for road safety hotspot prediction
Accident Analysis and Prevention ; 99 ; 262-271
2016-11-26
10 pages
Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)
Elektronische Ressource
Englisch
A novel Bayesian hierarchical model for road safety hotspot prediction
FID move | 2016
|A novel Bayesian hierarchical model for road safety hotspot prediction
Online Contents | 2017
|Road network safety evaluation using Bayesian hierarchical joint model
Elsevier | 2016
|Road network safety evaluation using Bayesian hierarchical joint model
Online Contents | 2016
|Prediction of road accidents: A Bayesian hierarchical approach
Elsevier | 2012
|