In recent years a new sub-field of moral psychology has emerged: moral psychology of AI and robotics. In this field there are several outstanding questions on how robot appearance and other perceived properties of the robots influences the way their decisions are evaluated. Researchers have observed that robot decision are not treated identically to human decisions, even if their antecedents and consequences are identical to human decisions. To study this moral judgment asymmetry effect further, two studies with a series of high conflict moral dilemmas were conducted: Study 1 – which used photorealistic full body imagery -- revealed that utilitarian decisions by human or non-creepy (i.e., nice) looking robotic agents were less condemned than “creepy” (i.e., unease inducing) robots, whereas “creepy” robots received higher moral approval when making deontological decisions. Furthermore, an exploratory analysis demonstrated that the creepiest robot did not cause moral surprise or disappointment when making utilitarian decisions. However, Study 2 showed that mere symbolic representation of the agent’s face did not trigger the Moral Uncanny Valley (where decisions of creepy robots are perceived negatively), suggesting that the effect is dependent on the photorealistic appearance of the agent. These results are in tension with some previous findings in robot moral judgment literature. Future research should focus on creating standardized stimuli for studying moral decisions involving robots and elucidating the complex interactions between agent appearance, decision type, and pre-decision expectations. This work deepens our understanding of the relationship between a decision-making agent’s appearance and the moral judgment of their decisions. The findings have significant implications for the design and implementation of autonomous agents in morally charged situations. ; Peer reviewed


    Zugriff

    Download


    Exportieren, teilen und zitieren



    Titel :

    Moral Uncanny Valley revisited : How human expectations of robot morality based on robot appearance moderate the perceived morality of robot decisions in high conflict moral dilemmas



    Erscheinungsdatum :

    27.11.2023


    Medientyp :

    Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)


    Format :

    Elektronische Ressource


    Sprache :

    Englisch



    Klassifikation :

    DDC:    629 / 170




    La influencia del efecto "Uncanny Valley" en el diseño de un robot social

    Garrell Zulueta, Anais / Sanfeliu Cortés, Alberto | BASE | 2010

    Freier Zugriff

    The Influence of Robot Personality on the Development of Uncanny Feelings towards a Social Robot

    Paetzel, Maike / Perugia, Giulia / Castellano, Ginevra | BASE | 2021

    Freier Zugriff

    Emergency procedures and moral dilemmas

    Vardy, A. / Wright, K. / University of Dundee et al. | British Library Conference Proceedings | 1998


    Networks of Social and Moral Norms in Human and Robot Agents

    Malle, B. F. / Scheutz, M. / Austerweil, J. L. | British Library Conference Proceedings | 2017