Automotive electrical and electronic systems (EES) comprise an area that has grown steadily in importance in the past decade and will continue to gain relevance in the foreseeable future. For this reason, the SEES project (Sustainable Electrical & Electronic System for the Automotive Sector) aims to contribute to cost-effective and eco-efficient EES components. Scenarios for the recovery of automotive EES are defined by taking into consideration the required improvements in EES design and the development and implementation of new technologies. The research project SEES is funded by the European Commission. This paper presents the findings of an assessment of the environmental and economic improvements for automotive EES from a system perspective, taking into account all life cycle steps. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) and Life Cycle Costing (LCC) case studies have been employed within the SEES project to define optimum design and end-of-life scenarios. These case studies have been applied to two selected EES components: an engine wire harness and a smart junction box, both manufactured by LEAR and assembled in an existing Ford car model. The component design has a significant impact on the product system and its processes, including its use and end-of-life (EOL) phase. For each of the analyzed components, two potential design alternatives have been compared with the original design, based on designers' recommendations from the status quo scenario results. These include the use of alternative wiring systems with a reduced copper content (flat flexible cable), lead-free solder alloys and new fixation mechanisms to facilitate disassembly. The overall EOL scenario determines the technologies of processes that must be modeled within the EOL phase of a product system. The analyzed end-of-life scenarios include: status quo car recycling and two alternatives: 1, disassembly for specific EES component recycling; 2, advanced post shredder recycling of shredding residues. The influences of the different design and EOL treatment scenarios on the LCA and LCC results have been analyzed. The most dominant life cycle phases for the LCA results are manufacturing (including raw material extraction and manufacturing of materials and components) and the use-phase. Similarly, manufacturing was the predominant phase during the LCC study. Disassembly costs were shown to be significant during the EOL phase. Among the analyzed design alternatives, the highest environmental improvement potential were gained from the use of alternative wiring systems with reduced weight and copper content, but with slightly increased life cycle costs. Smaller differences of the results were determined for the different end-of-life scenarios. The results of the EOL scenario depend on the component in question. The influence of variations in process data, model choices, e. g. which LCIA model was used for calculating the Human Toxicity Potential (HTP), which inventory data for copper production was used and other variables have been assessed in the sensitivity analysis. The sensitivity analysis demonstrates a strong dependency of results for HTP on the selected model. The presented results are based on a public report of the SEES project. The study has undergone a critical review by an external expert according to ISO 14040, § 7.3.2. The environmental impacts during the life cycle of the analyzed products are generally most strongly influenced by material production and the use phase of the products. In comparison, improvements during the EOL phase have only a very limited potential to reduce environmental impacts. The studied design changes displayed clear environmental advantages for (lighter) flat, flexible cables. Whereas, the lead-free solder design alternatives showed a slight increase in some environmental impact categories. The application of these design changes has been limited in some cases by technical issues. Focusing only on end-of-life improvements cannot be recommended for automotive EES products. A life-cycle perspective should be utilized for assessing improvements in individual life cycle stages of a product. The presented results will be an input for Eco-design guidelines for automotive EES, to be developed at a later stage within the SEES project.


    Zugriff

    Zugriff über TIB

    Verfügbarkeit in meiner Bibliothek prüfen


    Exportieren, teilen und zitieren



    Titel :

    Electrical and electronic components in the automotive sector: Economic and environmental assessment



    Medientyp :

    Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)


    Format :

    Print



    Environmental Specification for Automotive Electronic Components

    Joyce, P. / IEE | British Library Conference Proceedings | 1999


    Electrical environmental characteristics for automotive electronic systems

    Yamomoto, S. / Furuhashi, M. / Yamanaka, T. | Tema Archiv | 1977


    Electrical environmental characteristics for automotive electronic systems

    Yamamoto, S. / Ozeki, O. / Yamanaka, T. et al. | Tema Archiv | 1983


    Environmental Guidelines for the Designer of Automotive Electronic Components

    McCarter,O.T. / General Motors,Engng.Staff,Adv.Prod.Engng.Lab.,Warren,US | Kraftfahrwesen | 1974