Abstract Over the last ten years the concept of generalised cost has been gaining an increasing hold in both the theory and practice of transport planning, particularly in Britain and Australia; and in some circles it is now even beginning to be treated with awe as a major break-through with far reaching implications over a much broader area of economic analysis and public sector decision making. This article challenges the current orthodoxy, and suggests that the approach suffers from a number of major theoretical and practical weaknesses: principally that it gives an inaccurate and misleading representation of the interaction between variables relevant to a decision problem, providing little confidence that it can be of much use as a predictive tool; that it has no justification in theories of consumer behaviour, contrary to what is often supposed; and that there are considerable confusions set up by the British Government's recommended approach to evaluation and to the choice of measuring units. Most of these faults stem from falling into "index number traps" which involve reading into indices extra properties which they were not given when constructed, and which are often inconsistent with the basic principles on which they were designed. Five of these traps are discussed: the generalised cost index itself, together with the associated indices of elasticity, utility, time value and consumers' surplus. Suggestions are made not only about the kind of procedures that should replace the inappropriate generalised cost methodology, but also about how the current British practice should in any event be modified so as to eliminate as many as possible of its deficiencies.


    Zugriff

    Zugriff über TIB

    Verfügbarkeit in meiner Bibliothek prüfen

    Bestellung bei Subito €


    Exportieren, teilen und zitieren



    Titel :

    The generalised cost dilemma


    Beteiligte:

    Erschienen in:

    Erscheinungsdatum :

    1978




    Medientyp :

    Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)


    Format :

    Print


    Sprache :

    Englisch



    Klassifikation :

    BKL:    55.80 Verkehrswesen, Transportwesen: Allgemeines / 74.75 Verkehrsplanung, Verkehrspolitik
    Lokalklassifikation TIB:    535/7000



    Is generalised cost justified?

    Wardman, M. / Association for European Transport | British Library Conference Proceedings | 2008


    Has generalised cost any benefit?

    Grey, Alexander | Online Contents | 1978


    Microeconomic theory and generalised cost

    Bruzelius, Nils A. | Online Contents | 1981


    On Grey's critique of generalised cost

    Goodwin, P. B. | Online Contents | 1978


    Generalised cost: Fool's gold or useful currency?

    Searle, Geoffrey | Online Contents | 1978