Highlights Comparison of fatigue-related impairment to drug and alcohol-related impairment. A review of fatigue-related performance impairment. Findings suggest that work and driving performance is significantly impaired after less than 5 h prior sleep. The concept of ‘deemed impaired’ is introduced in the context of fatigue-related impairment.
Abstract In developed countries, deaths attributable to driving or working while intoxicated have steadily declined over recent decades. In part, this has been due to (a) public education programs about the risks and (b) the deterrence value associated with penalties and prosecutions based on an individual being ‘deemed impaired’ if they exceed a proscribed level of blood alcohol or drug concentration while driving/working. In contrast, the relative proportion of fatigue-related accidents have remained stubbornly high despite significant public and workplace education. As such, it may be useful to introduce the legal principle of ‘deemed impaired’ with respect to fatigue and/or sleep loss. A comprehensive review of the impairment and accident literature was performed, including 44 relevant publications. Findings from this review suggests that a driver or worker might reasonably be ‘deemed impaired’ once the amount of sleep falls below five hours in the prior 24. Building on the legal principles first outlined in recent New Jersey legislation (Maggie’s Law), this review argues that an individual can reasonably be ‘deemed impaired’ based on prior sleep wake behaviour. In Maggie’s Law, a driver can be indirectly ‘deemed impaired’ if they have not slept in the prior 24 h. Based on the extant literature, we argue that, relative to drug and alcohol intoxication, this may be overly conservative. While roadside measurement of fatigue and prior sleep-wake behavior is not yet possible, we suggest that public education programs should provide specific guidance on the amount of sleep required and that post-accident forensic examination of prior sleep wake behaviours may help the community to determine unsafe behaviours and liability more objectively than is currently the case.
How much sleep do you need? A comprehensive review of fatigue related impairment and the capacity to work or drive safely
2020-12-07
Aufsatz (Zeitschrift)
Elektronische Ressource
Englisch
Fatigue , Drink driving , Impairment , Law
Kraftfahrwesen | 1991
|The need for sleep: discriminating between fatigue related and non-fatigue related truck accidents
British Library Conference Proceedings | 1996
|Safely improving airport surface capacity
British Library Online Contents | 1998
Fatigue: Performance impairment, sleep and ageing in shiftwork operations
British Library Conference Proceedings | 1998
|Sleep, Torpor and Memory Impairment
British Library Conference Proceedings | 2006
|